Connect with us
ey1000x600 ey1000x600

News

The Wirecard case reveals a huge system failure by Ernst & Young – EY

The Wirecard scandal casts a bad light on the auditors. Everyone relied on them – and they failed. But German financial supervisors also have to put up with critical questions.

Germans fell for a huge fraud. Until June 18, Wirecard was considered a beacon of hope for the economy, which had made it into the German share index Dax. The group was worth twelve billion euros. The payment service provider filed for bankruptcy on Thursday. Wirecard is now worth 176 million euros.

It is now clear that much of the fantastic story was made up. The Wirecard name stands for the largest balance sheet fraud the Dax has ever experienced.

Martin Dahmen, Andreas Budde, Andreas Loetscher and Ralf Broschulat should have noticed that too. As the auditors, they had approved Wirecard AG’s balance sheets since 2013 and signed the corresponding attestations. All four were or are partners of Ernst & Young, which is now only called EY.

Ernst & Young has also audited the UK operation of Wirecard AG.

Holes in the balance sheet are probably even larger than previously known

The tests of these men and their assistants are the starting point for a huge system failure. Authorities, financial market professionals and thousands of retail investors have relied on the fact that the business figures that documented tremendous growth are correct. They probably weren’t.

Last Monday, the new Wirecard boss James Freis had to admit that balances in the amount of 1.9 billion euros did not exist in the balance sheet for 2019 “with a high probability” and that parts of the business did not take place as his predecessor Markus Braun claimed .

The holes in Wirecard’s numbers are likely to be even bigger. Otherwise the company would not have filed for bankruptcy as the banks were actually prepared to initially keep the company alive with a credit line of EUR 1.75 billion.

The fact that this thriller could happen under the eyes of all inspectors has a lot to do with the system in which examiners such as Dahmen, Budde, Loetscher and Broschulat work.

All four have spent almost their entire professional life at EY and two of them switched to other employers in 2018. The scene is small and they know each other and the supervisors and this is especially true for the partners at EY, KPMG, Deloitte or PwC, the so-called Big Four.

It is often criticized that companies not only check and audit the books but also provide advisory services.

“There are numerous conflicts of interest among the auditors. They are paid by the companies they are supposed to check, ”says Fabio De Masi, deputy  parliamentary leader in the Bundestag. In addition to the failure of the authorities, he criticizes that the liability of the auditors is too low. In fact, the gentlemen of EY are threatened with modest penalties as The German Commercial Code capped “the obligation to pay compensation for people who acted negligently” to four million euros per case.

EY denies all guilt. At Wirecard, “there is clear evidence that it is a comprehensive fraud involving several parties around the world and in various institutions with deliberate intent to deceive,” says EY. “Even with extensively expanded audit procedures, it may not be possible to detect this type of conspiratorial fraud.”

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 4.2 / 5. Vote count: 53

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

As you found this post useful...

Follow us on social media!

Latest Articles

india1000x600 india1000x600
India9 hours ago

Overwhelmed Indian Hospitals reject Covid 19 Patients

India is now the country with the fourth most corona infections and the country’s healthcare system is collapsing under this...

The main road of Sonagachi in Kolkata, India, during the lockdown in early April 2020. | Mukherjee Arindam/ABACA/ABACA/PA Images. All rights reserved. The main road of Sonagachi in Kolkata, India, during the lockdown in early April 2020. | Mukherjee Arindam/ABACA/ABACA/PA Images. All rights reserved.
India9 hours ago

Shutting down India’s red-light districts won’t contain coronavirus

Closing brothels in India would be a grand but empty gesture. It will only hide the state’s abandonment of migrants...

india1000x600 india1000x600
India9 hours ago

High number of new Covid-19 Infections in India again

Despite the almost two-month curfew, India once again reports a daily record for infections with the corona virus. The Ministry of...

marsalek-andwirecard marsalek-andwirecard
News1 day ago

The Bizarre Life of Jan Marsalek, the Number 2 at Wirecard – Eating Sushi from a naked woman’s body

The name Jan Marsalek now stands for one of the largest economic scandals in Germany. With Wirecard AG, he managed to...

pennystockwirecard pennystockwirecard
News1 day ago

Wirecard Shares on the way of Becoming a Penny Stock !

Wirecard has filed for bankruptcy and the business, or what is left of it, practically belongs to the creditors. Nevertheless,...

marsalek1000x600 marsalek1000x600
News2 days ago

Jan Marsalek Ex-COO of Wirecard AG – Catch me if you Can

Jan Marsalek, former Wirecard board member and COO, is sought worldwide and should be on EUROPOL and INTERPOL during this...

db1000x600 db1000x600
News2 days ago

Deutsche Bank is considering taking over Wirecard Bank

At the beginning of the week it still looked as if Wirecard’s Bank would also go into bankruptcy because too...

payoneer1000x600 payoneer1000x600
News2 days ago

Thousand’s of Payoneer Mastercard Holders still Affected by Wirecard UK and can’t Access their Funds in Pakistan Bangladesh & Balkan countries

Many of Payoneer’s millions of Freelancers have their freelance work paid into the card account, which is easier to open...

Carlos Haeuser, was not only a long-standing executive of Wirecard, but his wife, Brigitte Axtner Haeuser is Head of Digital Sales for Wirecard and a named director of WDAH in Singapore in the 2018 annual report. Carlos Haeuser, was not only a long-standing executive of Wirecard, but his wife, Brigitte Axtner Haeuser is Head of Digital Sales for Wirecard and a named director of WDAH in Singapore in the 2018 annual report.
News3 days ago

Singapore extends investigation into Wirecard Scandal with Citadel & Senjo Group

After IsaanLive reported last Thursday extensively on the Round-Tripping with Senjo Group based in Singapore, the Singapore authorities are expanding their...

Jan Marsalek1000x600 Jan Marsalek1000x600
News3 days ago

Wirecard : The Indian Round-Tripping Scam by COO Jan Marsalek

Was Wirecard’s Indian acquisition deliberately structured to generate round-trip profits through EMIF? Key questions about about Wirecard’s Indian business and...

Carlos Haeuser, was not only a long-standing executive of Wirecard, but his wife, Brigitte Axtner Haeuser is Head of Digital Sales for Wirecard and a named director of WDAH in Singapore in the 2018 annual report. Carlos Haeuser, was not only a long-standing executive of Wirecard, but his wife, Brigitte Axtner Haeuser is Head of Digital Sales for Wirecard and a named director of WDAH in Singapore in the 2018 annual report.
News3 days ago

Wirecard Round-Tripping Scam with Singapore & Luxembourg Companies

As we’ve been searching for where Wirecard’s MCA business is (and the bulk of it looks not to be in...

wirecardbank1000x600 wirecardbank1000x600
News3 days ago

Wirecard’s Merchant Cash Advance Scam in Brazil & Turkey

In November 2018 Wirecard claimed it had launched a new Merchant Cash Advance (MCA) Product and in both May and...

Jan Marsalek1000x600 Jan Marsalek1000x600
News3 days ago

Ex-Wirecard COO Jan Marsalek is wanted in Manila – Could he be in Mindanao Hiding?

Jan Marsalek, may be hiding in the Philippines. The COO had been fired last week and was responsible for day-to-day...

The Great Wirecard Scam The Great Wirecard Scam
News3 days ago

The Fall of Wirecard, Fraud, Round-Tripping, Money Laundering and the Web of Lies

It is not the first time, now in Germany, already back in 2017 they conducted the same schemes in Singapore...

markus-braun-103__v-videowebl markus-braun-103__v-videowebl
News3 days ago

Six Wirecard subsidiaries file for Bankruptcy – Balance Sheet Fraud has been going on since 2014

The Wirecard balance sheet scandal seems to be taking on ever larger dimensions. According to a media report, the management team...

Trending Now